Options head fake

  • Volume in CASY options nearly 6900% of average yesterday
  • Stock has diverged from broad-market rally this month
  • Recent price momentum may dictate path in absence of fundamental catalysts

Sometimes things come across your trading screen that take you in a direction you don’t initially expect.

Perusing LiveAction scans for unusual options activity yesterday morning showed convenience store chain Casey’s General Store (CASY) had a whole lotta options activity—more than 68 times average, in fact:

LiveAction scan: Unusual options volume. Heavy trading in CASY options

Source: Power E*TRADE

When you see numbers like that, you wouldn’t be surprised to see headlines about the stock popping up on your news feed, and you’d probably expect to see a big move on its price chart.

So, without further ado, here’s CASY’s daily chart from around 1 p.m. ET yesterday:

Casey’s General Stores (CASY), 11/21/18–3/20/19. Casey’s General Stores (CASY) price chart. Swinging lower.

Source: Power E*TRADE

Yes, the stock was trading to a roughly six-week low, but it was down only around 0.3% on the day. For comparison, the two stocks immediately below CASY on the LiveAction scan, FIS and NVRO, were down 1.5% and up 33%, respectively. (And there weren’t any CASY headlines, either.)

Reviewing the contract-by-contract volume in CASY options showed most of the action was taking place in two April strike prices (calls and puts) nearest to the stock price, but it also showed open interest (the number of unclosed options positions) was relatively low—far below the day’s volume, in fact. That suggests the heavy volume was more about traders liquidating existing trades than putting on new ones.

Where does that leave things? Casey’s reported quarterly numbers on March 11 (topping earnings but missing revenue estimates1), and with that potential catalyst off the table until June, traders may be focusing the momentum of the recent price action. Who knows, maybe some of the options liquidation was traders scaling back long positions in a stock that wasn’t trending, or taking profits on short options for the same reason?

The longer-term chart below shows that despite hitting a record high two weeks before earnings (around $138.50, the approximate average analyst price target2), CASY has actually been trading in a choppy range since last September:

Casey’s General Stores (CASY), 11/7/17–3/20/19. Casey’s General Stores (CASY) price chart. Choppy range.

Source: Power E*TRADE

Yesterday the stock was knocking on the door of its late-January lows around $125; if that threshold breaks, the December swing lows around $121 and $116 loom below. In the absence of a specific catalyst, some traders may expect the current momentum could take the stock to one or more of these levels before bulls decide prices are low enough for a true upside reversal.

Even if big numbers don’t always turn out to be what you think they are at first, they can still alert you to possible trades.

Market Mover Update: Levi Strauss & Co. is scheduled to begin trading today under the symbol LEVI, offering more than 36 million shares at a target range of $14–$16.1. May WTI crude oil futures topped $60/barrel yesterday for the first time in more than five months, pumping up energy stocks in the process.

Today’s numbers (all times ET): Bank of England announcement/minutes (8 a.m.), Leading Indicators (10 a.m.), EIA Natural Gas Report (10:30 a.m.).

Today’s earnings include: Carnival (CCL), Conagra (CAG), Darden Restaurants (DRI), G-III Apparel (GIII), Jefferies (JEF), KB Home (KBH).


Click here to log on to your account or learn more about E*TRADE's trading platforms, or follow the Company on Twitter, @ETRADE, for useful trading and investing insights.

1 StreetInsider.com. Casey's General Stores (CASY) Tops Q3 EPS by 21c, Revenue Misses. 3/11/19.

2 TipRanks. Analyst Price Targets. 3/20/19.

3 MarketWatch.com. Levi Strauss to offer 36.7 million shares in IPO priced at $14 to $16 each. 3/11/19.

What to read next...

So close, so far: A look at the market’s push toward new highs

Trading when vs. trading why Timing isn’t everything—unless you’re a short-term trader.

Tech stocks boom as market erases pullback with biggest up week of the year.

Looking to expand your financial knowledge?