Moment of truth?

  • PNC rallied Monday after falling 9.6% last week
  • Banks have slumped since last Wednesday’s FOMC meeting
  • PNC bounced after reaching support of February lows

If short-term traders always need to be ready to work either side of the market as opportunity allows, PNC Financial Services (PNC) likely gave bulls and bears plenty to consider yesterday.

Like most banks, PNC took a bit of a licking last week, as Wednesday’s Federal Reserve announcement made it clear that the central bank wasn't inclined to hike interest rates for the remainder of this year.1 Lower interest rates generally mean lower profit margins for commercial banks, and PNC reflected that dynamic by falling nearly 10% from its March 18 close by Friday:

PNC Financial Services (PNC), 12/19/18–3/25/19. PNC Financial Services (PNC) price chart. Sold off to support.

Source: Power E*TRADE

But when the broad market opened lower yesterday—with financials leading the downside charge—PNC was in the green. The final candle in the chart above shows the stock up around 1.1% a couple of hours into the trading session, when the S&P 500 (SPX) was up only 0.2% or so. At the same time, other banking stocks, including JPMorgan Chase (JPM), Citi (C), and Wells Fargo (WFC), had trimmed their losses considerably.

Also, PNC showed up on a LiveAction scan for unusual options activity—a high put-call (P/C) ratio:

LiveAction scan: High put-call ratio. Put options in play.

Source: Power E*TRADE

Because a high P/C ratio is sometimes a contrarian indicator at market bottoms—nervous traders often pile into put options during sharp sell-offs—some traders may have interpreted yesterday’s reading in PNC as bullish signal, especially since the stock was up on the day and the stock's down move had stalled around the support level defined by the February lows (approximately $119.40). Time for a “relief rally” after a possibly excessive drop?

Perhaps. But it also turned out that most of yesterday’s put volume (1,500 contracts, representing 150,000 shares of stock) was in the $117 options expiring this Friday. So, this means a put buyer may have been expecting a big down move in the next few days, while a seller was willing to collect the premium ($135,000 in this case, as the contracts traded at 0.9, or $90 each) and take the risk that such a sell-off wouldn’t occur. Which one will be correct?

Good question, and it’s also worth considering that the implications of this trade don’t extend beyond this Friday. Yesterday’s early stabilization in banks could have been interpreted as a sign that banks are due for at least a temporary rebound, even if they eventually move lower.

But it’s worth pointing out that, after their initial rebounds from their early lows yesterday, bank stocks were again drifting lower (along with the broad market) as the halfway point of the trading session approached, and PNC fell into negative territory for the day.

PNC Financial Services (PNC), 3/20/18–3/25/19. PNC Financial Services (PNC) intraday (5-minute) price chart. Hugging recent lows

Source: Power E*TRADE

The five-minute chart above shows PNC—despite trading sharply higher early yesterday—was still within the rough confines of a consolidation (trading range) that formed after the stock hit its lows on Friday.

Those lows are more or less the same as the support level shown on the daily chart. In the absence of more immediate upside momentum, short-side traders could by looking for a breakdown below that level to trigger a potential challenge to the stock’s December lows.

Market Mover Update: Housing stocks again bucked market weakness yesterday, with many high-profile homebuilders, including Lennar (LEN), KB Home (KBH), and DH Horton (DHI), gaining 3% or more (see “Wings of the dove”).

Today’s numbers (all times ET): Housing Starts (8:30 a.m.), S&P Corelogic Case-Shiller HPI (9 a.m.), FHFA House Price Index (9 a.m.), Consumer Confidence (10 a.m.).

Today’s earnings include: Cronos Group (CRON), FactSet (FDS), McCormick (MKC), KB Home (KBH), Ollie's Bargain Outlet (OLLI).


Click here to log on to your account or learn more about E*TRADE's trading platforms, or follow the Company on Twitter, @ETRADE, for useful trading and investing insights.

1 Reuters. Fed sees no rate hikes in 2019, plans balance sheet reduction slowdown. 3/20/19.

What to read next...

A Friday yield-curve inversion takes some of the starch out of a Fed-fueled rally.

Wednesday’s Fed announcement hit bank shares but sent homebuilders soaring.

A volume surge isn’t necessarily what it first appears to be, but that doesn’t mean there’s no trade opportunity.

Looking to expand your financial knowledge?